Comfort Tyler and the “Burr Conspiracy”

By October 14, 2018Uncategorized

One of Norm’s current projects is writing a narrative history of the larger Tyler family, beginning with immigrant Job Tyler, who arrived in Massachusetts in 1638. Norm is uncovering many good stories of relatives of which to be proud, but also some that are more problematic. One of the most intriguing stories is about Colonel Comfort Tyler, a well-respected early settler in upstate New York, who somehow got involved with the “Burr Conspiracy.”

The story goes thus: In 1800, Aaron Burr ran for president against Thomas Jefferson. The electoral votes were tied, and Burr felt cheated when Congress decided to give the presidency to Jefferson. A few years later Burr supposedly planned to get his revenge on Jefferson by establishing an independent country as part of the Louisiana Purchase, with himself as leader of this new rogue nation.

He needed an army, and for some unexplained reason Colonel Tyler felt it was a worthy cause and joined Burr’s campaign. Comfort was put in charge of recruiting soldiers, and he was very successful. Reportedly between August and December 1806 he attracted more than one thousand young men committed to join Burr’s largely disorganized effort.

Ultimately, only sixty or so recruits joined Burr and Tyler on boats headed southward down the Ohio and Mississippi Rivers.Escaping from numerous traps, they finally were captured in Louisiana. Burr and Tyler and other leaders were charged with treason and brought to trial in Virginia. Surprisingly, the charges were dismissed by Supreme Court Chief Justice John Marshall on the basis that no witnesses came forward, and although Burr had clandestine intentions, they had committed no treasonous act. After the trial, Comfort left quickly and returned to New York, where he spent the remainder of his life, but with his reputation tarnished.

This is one of many Tyler family stories I am uncovering and researching for the book. If interested in knowing about this story in more detail, you can read my draft version at: tylertopics.com/comfort.pdf

3 Comments

  • Jim Tyler says:

    Having lived in the Town of Onondaga, Onondaga County, NY I became familiar with Comfort Tyler including the Aaron Burr tale. Comfort Tyler, Ephriam Webster and Asa Danforth were the first white settlers in what was once called Onondaga Hollow in 1788. Reportedly Comfort Tyler was the first white man to boil brine from the salt springs near Onondaga Lake and produce salt.
    Jim Tyler, Dewey Beach, DE

  • Joann Green says:

    Interesting what stories unfold about our ancestors with some research!

  • Sherrie Lynn says:

    Fascinating!

Leave a Reply